Federal District Court Breaks New Ground In Allowing TABOR Lawsuit To Proceed
by Elliot Fladen | 12:29 pm, July 31, 2012 | Comments Off
Yesterday in Denver, U.S. District Judge William J. Martínez ruled that the lawsuit against Colorado’s Taxpayer Bill of Rights (known as “TABOR,” and which “limits state spending and bars lawmakers from raising taxes without a vote of the people”) could proceed partly under the theory that it violated “Republican Form of Government Clause” of Article IV, Section 4 of the United States Constitution. In so ruling, Judge Martínez boldly went where no Supreme Court Justice had gone before – she found that a case alleging a “Republican Form of Government” violation as its theoretical basis was justiciable (i.e. the Court could rule on it as opposed to being required to immediately dismiss it). Many cases, in fact, had held the opposite. See, e.g., Luther v. Borden, 48 U.S. (7 how.) 1 (1849), Pacific States Tel. & Tel. Co. v. Oregon, 223 U.S. 118 (1912); Baker v. Carr, 369 U.S. 186 (1962). It will be interesting to see whether there a possible future appeal on this point reaches the same result. It will also be interesting to see if any conservative legal groups/attorneys take the ruling as an invitation to challenge taxing and spending mandates approved through the initiative process that progressives have backed. See, e.g., (courtesy of the Reply Brief in the case) Colo. Const. art. IX, § 17 (Amendment 23, added by initiative in 2000); art. X § 21 (Tobacco Tax, added by initiative in 2004).
The Case is Kerr et al. v. Hickenlooper, No. 11-cv-1350-WJM-BNB (D. Colo.). More information on the progress of this case, including pertinent court filings, can be found here.
Elliot Fladen is a graduate of Stanford Law School and an attorney practicing law in Colorado Springs at The Fladen Law Center. Nothing in this column constitutes legal advice or begins an attorney-client relationship with Mr. Fladen.
Comments
Praise for PPC From Our Lefty "Fan"
- "Zany-ass bombast-entertainment...Hackneyed weirdo communist pseudo-nostalgia" --Alan Franklin, ProgressNow
Featured Posts
- PPC Training for Activists
UPDATE: Something apparently got messed up with the PayPal buttons during this past weekend’s database glitch – fixed now. Yes, it’s that time again — PPC will be conducting training classes for center-right activists on Saturday, April 20 and Saturday, April 27, at Independence Institute in Denver. The tentative class schedule is as follows: Saturday, [...]
- Holder’s First Letter to Paul Precipitates the Best Filibuster Ever
- The Lamest Twitter Argument Ever Offered?
- Return of the PPC Re-Education Camps – You Know You Want to Be There
- Supreme Courts Blesses Warrantless Surveillance of Citizens in a Kafkaesque Farce
- GOP Elite and the Ruling Class
- Do We Now Get to Call Joe Salazar a “Rapist”?
Follow PPC
Search
WayIn
Recent Posts
- The End
- Classes Cancelled
- Tyranny, guns and the statist alternative.
- Colorado Democrat Lawmakers to Sanction Voter Fraud
- Those budget ‘cuts’ are actually spending increases
- Hey, Colorado: Billion Dollar K-12 Tax Hike OR End the Education Plantation?
- War on Rural CO: Economic impact of SB 252
- Sunday night and gold and silver are crashing
- Scholarship Tax Credits Could Help Denver, Aurora HS Students Overcome Challenges
- Education Wonk Fest Tonight on Devil’s Advocate
Recent Comments
- Randy on The End
- Ben on The End
- freeboulder on The End
- Todd Shepherd on The End
- Keith on The End
- Richard G. Combs on Look Who Shot Herself in the Foot! (Hint, It’s Evie Hudak)
- Eileen on In Which Evie Hudak Likes Victims So Much That She Wants To Make More of Them
- Dean on In Which Evie Hudak Likes Victims So Much That She Wants To Make More of Them
- Eileen on One Flimsy White House Promise and a Classified Vote Later, And We Have A New CIA Director
- Dean on One Flimsy White House Promise and a Classified Vote Later, And We Have A New CIA Director
When a young girl gets close to the truth about a long-forgotten mystery, a harmless adventure becomes a threat to the future of the independent commercial settlements on Mars. 
Advertise Here!
Categories
Archives
Meta
Buy a Tea Party Poster!
